Landmark Myanmar genocide ruling piles pressure onto UN carbon market body

19 November 2026

By Oli Munnion

  • International Court of Justice has ruled that Myanmar’s military committed genocide against the Rohingya; the same military rulers have since gone on to commit countless more human rights abuses throughout the country
  • A cookstoves project in Myanmar was the first to be approved under the UN’s new “high integrity” carbon market system, but all but one of the project’s private investors have pulled out due to the risks involved
  • Verra, the world’s largest carbon market certification company, has suspended all activities in Myanmar, and verification company Earthood has been granted a third successive exemption from carrying out site visits due to the ongoing conflict

After seven years of deliberations, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) has finally ruled: Myanmar’s military was responsible for committing genocide against the Rohingya minority in Rakhine State in 2016 and 2017, and its actions since then have not mitigated any of the harm caused. 

In the proceeding years, the same military staged an attempted coup, plunging many more areas of the country into conflict and civil war. The head of Myanmar’s military at the time of the genocide has been installed by the junta as a civilian head of state, following sham elections held earlier this year.

Genocide is the crime of crimes. Whilst there is little hope that the military leaders and other perpetrators will be brought to justice any time soon, at the very least the UN and other international bodies need to make sure that their projects and programmes are not benefiting the military junta in any way, directly or indirectly.

Which is why it is so shocking that the Paris Agreement Crediting Mechanism’s Supervisory Body (PACM SB) is still refusing to suspend credits it issued from a cookstoves project in Myanmar. The supervisory body is responsible for overseeing the implementation of the UN’s new supposedly “high integrity” global carbon trading mechanism, under Article 6.4 of the Paris Agreement. Earlier this year it announced a major milestone; it had approved the first credits issued under the scheme, from the same project in Myanmar.

It soon became clear that for all but one month of the crediting period, the project had been implemented by a ministry under the direct control of the junta, a ministry that has been under international sanctions for years due to the fact that it bankrolls the military’s spending through its control of mining and logging operations in the country. What’s more, the project has been taking place in some of the areas that have seen the worst human rights abuses committed by the junta and its proxies since the attempted coup, including widespread gender-based violence.

The fact that this project was the first to be credited under the new mechanism was outrageous enough before the ICJ’s unprecedented ruling. But now that the military junta stands convicted of genocide by the world’s highest court, it could not be clearer that other UN bodies should have nothing to do with it, and should certainly not be providing it with financial incentives, via carbon credit sales, for example. For some reason though, the PACM SB is still dragging its heels.

Last month, all but one of the project’s private investors withdrew, leaving just SK Group, recipients of an open letter in August which called for their withdrawal too. One of the former investors, KEPCO, stated to Korean media that “with the local situation destabilised by the Myanmar military coup and the shift in the international carbon market framework complicating procedures, we judged that the project offered no utility relative to the risks and stopped it.”

In September, the world’s largest carbon market certification company Verra suspended all of its projects and activities in Myanmar. It stated that “Verra has decided not to advance any projects in Myanmar for the time being due to risks associated with the current international standing…and its governance, as well as various economic sanctions currently imposed by global institutions and government bodies.”

Whilst Verra is not involved in the PACM cookstoves project in Myanmar, it is a very bad look for the UN when even Verra, a scandal-hit company that has faced major scrutiny in recent years, has already taken action and suspended any credit issuances.

In June, Earthood Services Limited, an Indian company contracted to carry out the project’s verification process, received a third exemption from conducting site visits to verify the project’s emissions reductions claims. In the past, it has relied on a small number of remote video interviews instead, mostly with male heads of household, despite stove users being almost exclusively women. Whilst the first exemption was due to the pandemic, the next two were explicitly due to the “severe political instability and armed conflict” which has prevailed in Myanmar “since the military coup on February 1, 2021”. This means that not a single site verification visit has taken place at any point over the project’s three crediting periods.

Even more shockingly, Earthood stated in its letter to the PACM SB that “delaying the verification is not viable for the Coordinating/Managing Entity (CME), which depends on timely issuance of A6.4ERs for working capital.” The CME is South Korean NGO Climate Change Foundation (formerly Climate Change Centre), which in 2024 earned nearly 6 million Euros in income from the project, representing nearly 80% of its total income. The financial interests of Climate Change Foundation–which, let’s not forget, pays Earthood for their services–are clearly being prioritised over the integrity of the project’s emissions reductions claims.

We’re still waiting for a response to our open letter to the PACM SB sent in October, which was signed by over 130 civil society organisations. The letter called on them to immediately suspend further issuance and use of the project’s credits, and to commission an independent and comprehensive assessment of the project, pending further action. The pressure is clearly building, though. 

Whether or not they choose to do the right thing, the Paris Agreement’s flagship carbon market scheme has stumbled at the first hurdle, and it doesn’t bode well.

GFC-logo-lightgreen-EN
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful. Privacy Policy